As we enter the final week of the election campaign, messages from National and Labour (and their acolytes) are becoming very focused. The Winston Peters bogeyman line is the consistent theme being pushed by John Key and right wing commentators – see this covered in the following stories: John Armstrong’s Spectre of resurgent Peters has PM dancing to different tune and Audrey Young’s John Key’s new target: Winston.
Obviously New Zealand First is both a threat and an opportunity for National. It’s a threat because the Peters party has a very good chance of making it over the 5% threshold – and this is the only scenario in which National might reasonably be expected to lose power. The teapot tapes drama has given Peters invaluable media coverage at exactly the right time.
The nightmare scenario for National is this: Winston Peters clearing 5%, Act and United Future out of parliament and National trending downwards to below 48%. Under this situation National could still lose what once seemed to be an unloseable election.
PublishOf course it’s also an opportunity for National to scare their voters out of complacency, to frighten wavering voters who may not want National to have absolute power but still want a National government, and to terrify the National voters of Epsom into supporting John Banks. Other important or interesting items on this include: Dim Post’s Dogwhistle of the day and Imperator Fish’s very funny blog post, Trying Hard To Lose which paints a picture of the extremes Paul Goldsmith might be forced to go to in order to throw the election in Epsom.
Labour has two straws remaining to which they are clutching for dear life. The first is that there is an outside chance they can still win the election. No one likes voting for losers and so they have to be seen as being contenders in the last week. The rise of Winston Peters – even though it may be partially at a cost to their own vote – actually gives Labour some slim hope. So despite Peters taking equal whacks at Labour as well as National, Labour are biting their tongues.
The only real ammunition Labour has left is opposition to asset sales and they will hammer this for the rest of the week – see: Audrey Young’s two items, Labour stakes it all on stopping asset sales and Goff: 'New Zealand is not for sale'. Even so, blogger Steven Cowan raises questions about the authenticity of Labour’s campaign on this issue. See Empty posturing over state assets.
Apart from asset sales there is a chance that no other actual policy might see the light of day in this campaign, although TV3 is screening what looks like a very interesting and heavily political documentary tomorrow night – see: Michelle Duff’s Shock look at NZ's child poverty. On issues of inequality, also see Tapu Misa’s Differing values widen the chasm.
It’s likely that the teapot saga will continue to dominate as it has for the past week. Although the issue is probably irritating and boring the vast majority of voters and politicos, it just won’t die. Today the Herald is supposed to be subjected to a Police search warrant, tomorrow the cameraman will get his day in the High Court, and on Wednesday TVNZ is expected to receive their visit from the Police. This will continue to impact negatively on the two major parties, raising further questions about the Prime Minister’s handling of the matter, and depriving Labour of much needed media attention. Winston Peters and the Greens will hope the controversy carries on, boosting their chances for Saturday.
Items worth reading on the teapot tapes include: Vernon Small’s Tea party rivals Alice's stupidest ever, Vernon Small and Kate Chapman’s Tape talk private, say voters, John Armstrong’s The best and the worst of weeks for John Key, the Herald editorials Teapot affair too trivial for raids on media and Key counts cost of evasiveness, the Standard’s How bad are National’s internals?, and Andrew Geddis’ Time for a cup of tea, perhaps.
Other important reads today are: Mathew Grocott’s Massey poll survey gives interesting reading, Rob Salmond’s Poll of polls update, and some projections, too, and Bernard Hickey’s Politicians avoiding main concerns. [Continue reading below for a full list of the highlights of NZ Politics Daily]
Key targets Peters
TVNZ: Key aims to rain on Winston's parade
Dim Post: Dogwhistle of the day
Steven Price (Media Law Journal): Memo to John Key
John Armstrong (NZH): Spectre of resurgent Peters has PM dancing to different tune
Audrey Young (NZH): John Key's new target: Winston
Tracy Watkins (Stuff): PM warns of Winston Peters
TVNZ: Key warns of 'instability' with Peters
Paloma Migone (Stuff): Peters: I won't destabilise the Government
The Standrard: Fearing Winston
Labour’s final week strategy – asset sales
Audrey Young (NZH): Labour stakes it all on stopping asset sales
RNZ: Maori Party to push for asset deal for iwi
Claire Trevett (NZH): Distractions show pair better off with issues that matter
Audrey Young (NZH): Goff: 'New Zealand is not for sale'
Steven Cowan (Against the current): Empty posturing over state assets
TVNZ: Goff pins hopes on asset sales angst
RNZ: Preferential deal for iwi and asset sales ruled out
Grant Bradley (NZH): Sale of SOEs likely to lift directors' fees
John Hartevelt and Vernon Small (Dom Post): Time to get over 'cup of sour tea'
John Hartevelt (Stuff): Goff promises week of hard Labour
Audrey Young (NZH): Labour has goody-bag of tricks for final week
John Hartevelt (Stuff): Election's about economy, says Labour
John Hartevelt (Stuff): It’s time for straight talking, says Labour
Inequality in NZ
Michelle Duff (Stuff): Shock look at NZ's child poverty
TV3: Child poverty killing hundreds – report
Shabnam Dastgheib (Dom Post): Growing wealth gap alarms charities
John Hartvelt (Stuff): Greens highlight child poverty
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): A taxpayer funded free hour for Labour in election week
Tapu Misa (NZH): Differing values widen the chasm
Waikato Times: Editorial - MPs' $5000 'Christmas bonus' seems a bit rich
Teapot tapes
John Armstrong (NZH): The best and the worst of weeks for John Key
Vernon Small (Stuff): Tea party rivals Alice's stupidest ever
NZH: Editorial - Teapot affair too trivial for raids on media
Herald on Sunday: Editorial - Key counts cost of evasiveness
David Fisher (NZH): Tea tape: Police to move on paper
Brian Rudman (NZH): Plots over the teacups, lunacy over the radio, officialdom over the top
TV3: Police hold off on teapot tape search warrants
Derek Cheng (NZH): Tea tape: Here come the police
Derek Cheng (NZH): Cameraman swears teacup tape not deliberate
Taranaki Daily News: Editorial - A tea break is a long time in politics
Vernon Small and Kate Chapman (Stuff): Tape talk private, say voters
NZH: Public divided over tea cup tape: poll
The Standard: How bad are National’s internals?
TV3: VIDEO: Bryce Edwards on the election campaign
TV3: Colin James on the 'Tea Gate' saga
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Paul Holmes on the media
Andrew Geddis (Pundit): Time for a cup of tea, perhaps
David Fisher (NZH): Election 2011: Police told of tea tape 'on principle'
RNZ: Media 'can't ignore tea tapes'
RNZ: Mediawatch for 20 November 2011(audio)
Steven Price (Media Law Journal): Hosking lays down the law
Mai Chen (NZH): Privacy, intent and the teapot tape: four key questions
Fran O’Sullivan (NZH): I feel your pain, but harden up
Grant Duncan (Policy Matters): Policy Matters
TV3: Michael Laws would shoot "rabid" journalists
Steven Price (Media Law Journal): Huh?
Adam Hollingworth (TV3): 'Laws may have overstepped the mark'
Deborah Coddington (NZH): Tape at top of slippery slope to controlled media
Kerre Woodham (NZH): Media distrust lucky for PM
Paul Holmes (NZH): Media behaving like a lynch mob over private conversation
Sean Plunket (NZH): 'Tea and sympathy' conspicuously missing
Rachel Glucina (NZH): Political Spy: One cup of tea and they all turn mad
Derek Cheng (NZH): PM rules out apology to cameraman
Derek Cheng (NZH): Key faces tea tape libel threat
Strategic voting
Patrick Gower (TV3): Dirty deals in Ohariu - extended footage
Stuff: Nats plead for Ohariu party vote
Imperator Fish: Trying Hard To Lose
Matt McCarten (NZH): Progressive tactics for a fairer Parliament
Dene Mackenzie (ODT): Tactical voting to fore with cuppa saga
Polling
Rob Salmond (Pundit): Poll of polls update, and some projections, too.
Stuff: Surprise poll results no shock for a defiant Winston
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): A major fail by the SST
Idealog: Health, environment and safety top the list of NZers future concerns
Michelle Nicol (liberation): Do opinion polls influence voters? (1): Introduction
Kiwipolitico: Teapot Tapes poll: political moral suasion
Coalition possiblities
Mathew Grocott (Stuff): Massey poll survey gives interesting reading
TV3: Maori party under pressure to declare election alliance
Robert Winter (Idle Thoughts): Pita Sharples: Vanquisher of ACT? Or Promoter of Mana?
RadioLIVE: Maori party candidate fears for safety
Maori vote
Morgan Godfery (Pundit): Labour’s bold play for the Maori vote
RNZ: Mana Party expects to attract Labour votes
RNZ: Claim two Maori political parties in Parliament unsustainable
David Fisher (NZH): Sharples aide to face email probe
The Worm
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): The worm
Imperator Fish: Waiting For The Worms
Anthony Robins (The Standard): Debate tonight – smartphone worm app
Policy releases
Audrey Young (NZH): Mana Party releases its foreign policy
Kathryn Powley (NZH): Election 2011: Party policy promises
Lindsay Mitchell (NZH): Labour welfare policy a sham
Janet McAllister (NZH): Ironies in acres of arts policy white space
Leader profiles/interviews
Audrey Young and John Armstrong (NZH): Phil Goff interview: 'I'll stop asset sales dead.'
TVNZ: Q+A interview with Phil Goff
Jonathan Milne (NZH): Election 2011: Goff ready for the hard decisions
John Armstrong and Audrey Young (NZH): 'Who wants a PM who's down in the mouth?'
Kate Chapman (Stuff): 'Cool' Key tries a Pimm's in the sun
Jonathan Milne (NZH): Election 2011: Key ducking the questions
TVNZ: Q+A interview with John Key
TVNZ: Q+A interview with Winston Peters
Deborah Coddington (NZH): Dining with the leaders: Whanau focus fuels final charge
Election campaign
Audrey Young (NZH): English and King backed as best new leaders
Felix Marwick (Newstalk ZB): Push for scrutiny over election promises
Bernard Hickey (NZH): Politicians avoiding main concerns
Brian Fallow (NZH): Risk factor of global crisis ignored
Damien Grant (NZH): Blueprint ready, bravery lacking
NZH: PM avoids question on work by 'chosen' family
Bevan Hurley (NZH): Girl Key took to Waitangi opts for Aussie
Taranaki Daily News: Editorial – Why we need youth more involved
RNZ: More young Maori have enrolled this election
RNZ: Maori urged to vote this election
Katherine Forbes (Stuff): NZ rap star's vote message
John Weekes (NZH): Election 2011: Minor leaders seize chance
John Weekes (NZH): 'Heavy-handed' end to Onehunga campaign train
Joanne Carroll (NZH): Election cyber wars: Tweets just keep on coming
Rhiannon Horrell (Stuff): Crude ‘foetus’ poster causes offence
Steve Kilgallon (SST): Billboard artist turns suburb into mo town
Jonathan Milne (NZH): National candidate: No link to $8b case
Stuff: Campaign diary: Monday, November 21
Dom Post: Campaign diary: Saturday, November 19
Electorate profiiles
Yvonne Tahana (NZH): Te Tai Tokerau: Sitting MP faces stiff challenge
Yvonne Tahana (NZH): Tamaki Makaurau electorate: Housing an issue for city Maori
Dene Mackenzie (ODT): Politicians flounder on rocks