The Opposition parties are not about to give up on the anti-asset sales campaign despite the Government having squeaked through the sale legislation yesterday. And why would they? Not only do they have an issue that puts them onside with a sizable majority of voters, but the issue is proving incredibly useful in uniting Labour, the Greens and New Zealand First. And for a change, they have been disciplined about attacking the Government, not each other. This ability to work together and punish the Government’s many weaknesses lately – especially over assets sales – has made their political alliance appear more formidable than ever. But just how united and effective is this new coalition? [Read more below]
For an insight into how things are going, both in front of the cameras and behind the scenes, this week’s must-read article is Jonathan Milne’s Unholy alliance: National's united opposition. Competitive tensions are still evident, particularly in Grant Robertson’s comments about the Greens, and the real test will be to maintain the focus of their attacks through 2014. Like many relationships, as long as the going is good it will be easy, but if one party starts to gain at the other’s expense then the alliance will cease being so cosy on the Opposition side of the House. Naturally, there is already some feeling that the Greens continue to do better out of the anti-asset sales campaign than Labour – see, for example Robert Winter’s blogpost, Greens marginalising Labour in the media?.
Labour is promising much more action on the asset sales, especially as the petition and referendum gather momentum – see Dene Mackenzie’s Unrest predicted as petition grows and asset-sale moves proceed, but the Greens have also invested heavily in the petition’s success. A successful petition and referendum for the parties has more, of course, to do with the next election than actually stopping the sales. While they can claim the class size and conservation mining backdowns prove National can actually be stared down, it is almost inconceivable that the Government would bow to a non-binding poll in which the result is pretty much a forgone conclusion.
The most likely fly in the ointment for the privatisation programme will probably come from ‘the market’. Vernon Small’s A Mighty flop might sink sales looks at the balancing act the Government must perform to ensure both taxpayers and the legendary (mythical?) ‘mum and dad investors’ aren’t feeling ripped off after the sales. Even if the price is ‘not too hot and not too cold’ the normal profit-taking that often follows large floats bears political risk.
There are also the ever present dangers of successful court challenges, not only because they may delay the sales, but because precautionary measures to head them off, such as reserving shares for treaty settlements, are politically toxic – see Adam Bennett’s Legal fight over asset sales likely. The Prime Minister seems confident that the challenges ‘have no merit’, but University of Otago law lecturer Jacinta Ruru disagrees – see: Iwi case over asset sale valid – Expert. The Government has been warned by the Maori Council not to try and play ‘Maori off against Maori’ to get around the challenges – listen to the RNZ interview, Maori Council decries one-off compensation for Tuwharetoa.
Inevitably there will also be stories like this one: Mighty River bosses get extra $220k for sell-off – which, along with yesterday’s reports that the directors are looking to double their pay rate to $2,400 a day after the sale, will jar with the Government’s theme of fiscal restraint.
There has also been a lot of odium heaped on Peter Dunne for providing the one vote needed for the sales – see TV3’s Labour blames Dunne for close vote. Some got over-excited, however, with Labour MP Megan Woods proving that ‘Godwins Law’ (comparing your opponents to Hitler or the Nazis) is alive and well on her twitter account. Such references don’t cause much outrage these days – just instant (and deserved) ridicule – see TV3’s Labour MP apologises for Hitler tweet. David Farrar takes it all seriously and actually compares Hitler’s mandate to the current government – see: Labour on Dunne and Nazis. Clearly the Labour MP lost the argument the moment she pushed send.
Finally on the asset sales debate, for a socialist critique of the parliamentary opposition to asset sales, see Tom Peters’ article, Labour, Greens continue “Keep Our Assets” diversion. This points out some of the weaknesses and contradictions of those opposing the asset sales, including the point that ‘the claim on the “Keep Our Assets” web site that electricity is currently “affordable” because “the publicly-owned companies hold the price down” is patently false’.
- Labour’s latest staffing recruit is Julian Robins from Radio NZ’s Parliamentary press gallery. This prompted satirist TV3’s Ali Ikram (@alidram) to tweet: ‘If a Radio New Zealand reporter moves into PR for the Labour Party does that constitute a shift to the Right?’. David Farrar also commented that ‘I think this is the 5th press gallery journalist in the last three years to join the Labour or Greens media teams’ – see: Gallery to Labour. A subsequent blog comment did name, however, at least thirteen journalists employed by National.
- Scientific advice appears to have been put to the side in a decision to allow exploration in marine sancturies – see: Otago scientist 'ignored' in mining decision, but the Dominion Post editorial thinks the latest proposals for surveying our potential mineral wealth are a good idea – see: It won't hurt to have a look. No Right Turn responds that such an attitude is akin to ‘a child saying they want to count the sweets but not eat any’ – see: More orcishness.
- The Government has been told by the Labour Department that new job opportunities are not likely to be suitable for those that National are looking to move off long term benefits – see: Low-skilled workers, women to miss out on Govt jobs – report.
- The horse may have already bolted when it comes to concerns about the Trans Pacific Partnership giving rights to overseas companies to sue our government, says Jason Krupp – see: Six deals give foreign investors protections and Foreign lawsuits already a threat.
- Who is the new Reserve Bank boss? is a good background article by James Weir about the man in charge of the money supply, while today’s Herald editorial wants beating inflation to remain his number one priority – see: Bank chief should stick to old target (http://bit.ly/M1QUhB).
- Business is booming for uber-public law firm Chen Palmer, leading to an expansion into Auckland – see: Mai Chen moves to Auckland. Chen’s explanation is reported: ‘“The great thing is that the government keeps me in business," she said, with more regulation being introduced regardless of who was in power’.
- Reporting on Winston Peters’ current ‘furious, high-speed’ style in parliamentary debates, Jane Clifton says that the New Zealand First leader no longer bothers to include spaces between his words: ‘Mr Peters asked whether Prime Minister John Key had "misledthepublic" by "selectivelyusinganumberof-fourteenthousandonehundredandthirtyfive", when the real number was "fifteenthousandfourhundredandninetynine".’ – see: Speedy Peters' row turns chow mein.
- Finally, the blogwars between Scott Yorke and Martyn Bradbury are apparently over – see Yorke’s blogposts Oh Martyn, Must We? and The End Of The Affair. Yorke also reports on some tweeter correspondence between John Key and ‘Peter Dunne’ in #SwimAtKeys.
Adam Bennett (Herald): Legal fight over asset sales likely
David Fisher (Herald): Mighty River bosses get extra $220k for sell-off
Vernon Small (Dom Post): A Mighty flop might sink sales
Danya Levy (Stuff): Dunne's vote seals asset sales
Dene Mackenzie (ODT): Unrest predicted as petition grows and asset-sale moves proceed
Newswire: Fight to stop asset sales continues
Kate Shuttleworth (Herald): Asset sales protesters gather at Parliament
Tom Peters (WSWS): New Zealand: Labour, Greens continue “Keep Our Assets” diversion
Robert Winter (Idle Thoughts): 61-60: Mr Dunne has a lot to answer for
Abby Gillies (Herald): Outrage over MP's Nats-as-Hitler comment
Greg Presland (Waitakere News): Is John Campbell or John Key the financial illiterate?
Cameron Slater (Whaleoil): The lies of the left
Keeping Stock: The SMOG's continue...
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): John Key's Master Plan
The Standard: Facepalm
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Labour on Dunne and Nazis
Tumeke: Going, going…
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): #SwimAtKeys
Kate Shuttleworth (Herald): Mining, surveying to go ahead in marine sanctuaries
Nathan Argent (Dom Post): Govt's scant regard for danger
Dom Post: Editorial: It won't hurt to have a look
No Right Turn: More orcishness
Chris Trotter (Bowalley Road): Rio + 20
Ben Clark (The Standard): Rio: another chance lost
Claire Trevett (Herald): Bennett tells abused state victims to claim
Jamie Morton (Herald): Long-range battle with ACC over girl's care
Phil Kitchin (Stuff): ACC's $250 compo for breaches 'pathetic' – victim
Paul Harper (Herald): 'They might as well not bother'
Simon Cunliffe (ODT): ACC tinkering leaves culture of nastiness
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Is the taxpayer funding Mallard and Little’s legal fees
Jonathan Milne (Herald): Unholy alliance: National's united opposition
Simon Collins (Herald): No baby boom and fewer sheep: Myths busted
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): Gallery to Labour
Robert Winter (Idle thoughts): Greens marginalising Labour in the media?
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): The End Of The Affair
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): Oh Martyn, Must We?
Jason Krupp (Stuff): Foreign lawsuits already a threat
Rob Hosking (NBR): Govt promises reduction in compliance costs for business
Benje Patterson (Stuff): Don't blame state for unemployment
Andrea Vance (Stuff): Sex offenders to be tracked by satellite
Jason Krupp (Stuff): Six deals give foreign investors protections
James Weir (Stuff): Who is the new Reserve Bank boss?
Brian Fallow (Herald): Business as usual - with tweaks maybe
Susan St John and Claire Dale (Herald): Claire Dale and Susan St John: NZ needs to smarten up Super rules
Morgan Godfery (Maui Street): Best and worst performing Maori MPs for June
Taranaki Daily News: Editorial: Education before point-scoring
Bernard Orsman (Herald): Nomination for 'best mayor' honour news to Brown
David Farrar (Kiwiblog): The local government league table
Jane Clifton (Stuff): Speedy Peters' row turns chow mein
Russell Brown (Hard News): The frustrating politics of drug reform
Stuff: Mai Chen moves to Auckland